First Impression That Wins Clients: 12 Psychology-Backed Strategies Every Creative Professional Needs

Everyone hopes to make a positive first impression with clients, models, colleagues, and others.
You're meeting a potential client for the first time. Perhaps it's a nervous bride clutching her mood board, or a corporate marketing director who needs headshots for fifty executives by Friday, or it's your first day in the office with new colleagues. Within seconds (literally just one second, according to a Princeton research), they've formed an impression that could make or break your creative relationship.

This is something I have learned the hard way during my years in the industry. That moment when you realise a perfectly good client conversation went sideways, not because your portfolio wasn't impressive enough or your rates were wrong, but because something indefinable just… didn't click.
The truth is, as creative professionals working in an increasingly competitive market, we can't afford to leave first impressions to chance.

The creative industry has undergone a significant transformation in recent years. With 2024 data showing that the market for generic photography has become saturated, standing out is no longer just about technical skill: it's about human connection.
Remote collaborations have become the norm, making those initial moments of contact more crucial than ever. Whether you're pitching to clients via Zoom from your home studio or meeting them at a bustling networking event, your ability to create an instant rapport can determine whether you land that dream project or watch it slip away to a competitor.

But here's what most creatives don't realise: the science of making a brilliant first impression with clients isn't mysterious. It's measurable, learnable, and surprisingly practical. Today's most successful photographers and designers (and every other professional) aren't just relying on their creative talents: they're using psychology-backed strategies that work at a neurological level to build trust, establish credibility, and create the kind of magnetic presence that clients remember long after the meeting ends.

Photography and Design are the industries I've known for the past 30 years, which is why I specifically discuss them. However, everything I write here can be applied anywhere, even outside of a work environment.

The Neuroscience Behind Creative Connections

Before we explore specific strategies, it's worth understanding what's actually happening in your client's brain during those first few moments. Recent neuroscience research reveals that when we meet someone new, our brains are simultaneously processing information through multiple systems (most of the studies I reference here are linked at the end of this article).

Mirror neurons (specialised brain cells that fire both when we perform an action and when we observe someone else performing the same action) play a starring role in this process. They're essentially creating a mental simulation of the person we're interacting with, helping us understand their emotions and intentions. For creative professionals, this biological reality presents an incredible opportunity.

When a client walks into your studio or joins your Zoom meeting, their mirror neurons are already at work, helping them read you. They're unconsciously picking up on your posture, facial expressions, and energy levels, and their brain is mirroring these qualities back to them. It may sound scary at first, but this is why a photographer who appears genuinely excited about a wedding project can spark corresponding enthusiasm in their couple, or why a designer who radiates calm confidence can immediately put nervous corporate clients at ease.

Ad from Trusted Partners

The Chameleon Effect, our tendency to unconsciously mimic others' behaviours, adds another layer to this dance. Research published in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology shows that when people feel subtly mirrored, they're more likely to trust and engage positively with the person doing the mirroring. This isn't about manipulation; it's about creating genuine rapport through our natural social wiring.

Understanding these mechanisms transforms how we approach client relationships. Every gesture, every tone of voice, every micro-expression is an opportunity to build connection at a fundamental level.

12 Strategies For The Win

Strategy 1: Master the Art of Subtle Mirroring

The most powerful technique in making a good first impression with clients isn't what you say: it's how you unconsciously make your client feel understood. Professional mimicry, when done skillfully, creates an instant sense of harmony that your clients will notice on a subconscious level.

During client consultations, pay attention to their communication style. If they speak slowly and thoughtfully, resist the urge to rush in with rapid-fire suggestions. Match their pace naturally. When they lean forward with excitement while describing their vision, allow yourself to mirror that energy appropriately. If they're more reserved and measured, adopt a similarly considered approach.

Body language offers countless opportunities for subtle synchronisation. Notice how they position themselves: are they sitting forward on the edge of their chair, engaged and excited? Or are they leaning back, arms loosely crossed, taking a more evaluative stance? Gently adapting your posture to complement theirs (not copy exactly) can create an unconscious sense of alignment.

The key word here is subtle. Heavy-handed mimicry feels forced and uncomfortable. Think of it more like tuning a musical instrument: you're adjusting your energy to harmonise with theirs, not drowning them out with identical notes.

I remember working with a particularly detail-oriented Art Director who spoke in precise, measured sentences and took careful notes throughout our initial meeting. Instead of overwhelming her with my usual enthusiastic presentation style, I consciously slowed down, spoke more deliberately, and took notes myself. By the end of our conversation, she mentioned feeling “completely understood” and signed on for a major campaign. The project became one of my most successful collaborations, largely because we established that initial rapport through unconscious mirroring. The project details are not important here, but you can always check my LinkedIn to figure it out.

This technique works brilliantly in virtual meetings too. Pay attention to how your client frames themselves on camera, their speaking rhythm, and even their energy levels. A tired-looking client at 9 AM might need gentle, supportive energy rather than boundless enthusiasm.

Strategy 2: Create Space for Their Story

One of the most profound ways to make someone feel valued is to genuinely listen to them speak about themselves. Neuroscience research shows that talking about ourselves activates the same reward centres in our brains as food and money; it literally feels good. Yet many creative professionals make the mistake of dominating early conversations with their own portfolios, processes, and achievements.

Instead, master the art of strategic silence. After introductions, ask an open-ended question that invites them to share their vision, then create genuine space for their response. This might sound like: “I'd love to understand what brought you to this project”, or “Tell me about how you're envisioning this coming together.”

Then—and this is crucial—resist the urge to immediately jump in with solutions. Let them finish completely. Ask follow-up questions that show you're processing what they've shared. “When you mention wanting something ‘timeless,' what does that look like in your mind?” or “That sounds like it has real personal significance, can you tell me more about that aspect?”

This approach serves multiple purposes. First, it positions you as a consultant rather than just a service provider. Consultants listen, analyse, and provide tailored solutions. Service providers simply execute instructions. Second, it gives you invaluable insight into their actual needs versus their stated requirements. Often, what clients initially request isn't what they actually need, and this deeper conversation reveals the real brief.

Most importantly, it makes them feel heard and understood from the very beginning. When someone feels truly listened to, they automatically begin to trust the listener. They start thinking of you as someone who “gets it” rather than someone trying to sell them something.

During wedding consultations, I've found that couples often reveal their deepest concerns and dreams during these unguarded moments. A bride might mention feeling overwhelmed by family expectations, or a groom might quietly admit he's nervous about being photographed. These insights become the foundation for creating not just beautiful images, but an entire experience that addresses their real needs.

Don't inquire: I no longer do weddings.

Strategy 3: Lead with Questions in Professional Settings

In business environments, there's often an invisible power dynamic at play. Clients may feel they need to establish authority, or they might be defensive about budget constraints or previous bad experiences with creatives. The temptation is to counter this by immediately establishing your own credentials and expertise.

Research in social psychology suggests a different approach: lead with genuine curiosity about their business challenges. This immediately shifts the dynamic from adversarial to collaborative. Instead of two parties trying to establish dominance, you become partners solving a problem together.
Amy Cuddy's research on first impression with clients reveals that warmth (the sense that someone cares about and understands us) must be established before competence can be effectively demonstrated. Starting with questions about their business, their goals, and their challenges communicates warmth immediately.

Try opening business meetings with questions like: “Before we get into the creative brief, help me understand the bigger picture: what's happening in your business right now that makes this project particularly important?”, or “What would success look like for you beyond just getting great images?”

This approach often uncovers crucial context that wouldn't appear in a standard creative brief. Perhaps they're launching in a new market and need to establish credibility quickly. Maybe they're rebranding after a difficult period and need to rebuild trust. Understanding these deeper business motivations allows you to position your creative solutions as business solutions, not just aesthetic ones.

The question-first approach also demonstrates confidence. Insecure creatives often feel compelled to immediately justify their presence with credentials and portfolio pieces. Confident professionals ask thoughtful questions because they know their expertise will become apparent as the conversation unfolds.

Strategy 4: Share Strategic Vulnerability

Conventional wisdom suggests that first meetings require putting your best foot forward, and that's partially true. However, recent research in interpersonal psychology reveals something counterintuitive: strategic vulnerability can actually strengthen professional relationships more quickly than polished perfection.

The key is timing and appropriateness. After you've established basic competence and rapport, sharing a carefully chosen challenge or learning experience can make you more relatable and trustworthy. This might be discussing how you've evolved your approach to a particular type of project, or mentioning a lesson learnt from a challenging client situation.

For photographers, this could sound like: “I've photographed dozens of corporate events, and I've learnt that the real magic happens in those unguarded moments between the formal presentations. Early in my career, I focused too much on the scheduled shots and missed some of those authentic interactions. Now I always build in time to capture the conversations that happen naturally.”

For designers, it might be: “One thing I've discovered over the years is that clients often think they need a complete rebrand when what they actually need is strategic refinement. I once spent weeks developing completely new concepts for a client before realising we should start by understanding what was already working in their current approach.”

This vulnerability serves several purposes. It demonstrates self-awareness and a growth mindset, qualities that savvy clients value highly. It also shows that you view your work as an ongoing process of refinement rather than a fixed set of abilities. Most importantly, it invites them to be equally open about their own uncertainties or concerns.
The crucial element is ensuring your vulnerability demonstrates learning and growth rather than incompetence. You're not admitting to fundamental flaws in your work; you're sharing how your approach has become more sophisticated over time.

Strategy 5: Master the Art of Strategic Presence

In our hyperconnected world, simply being physically present has become a rare gift. Yet many creative professionals undermine their first impression with clients by failing to create true presence during initial meetings. They're mentally jumping ahead to portfolio presentations (something I often don't show at all), worried about time constraints, or distracted by the constant ping of notifications.

True presence, the quality of being completely engaged with the person in front of you, creates an almost magnetic quality that clients find incredibly appealing. When someone feels that you're entirely focused on them and their project, they automatically assume you'll bring that same level of attention to your work.
My workshops are designed for individuals or small groups, so I can give each participant my full attention.

This means creating environmental conditions that support presence. If you're meeting in your studio, ensure your phone is in another room, not just face down on the table. If you're in a coffee shop, choose a table away from high-traffic areas where you won't be distracted by movement. For virtual meetings, close unnecessary browser tabs and applications.

But presence goes beyond removing distractions. It's about bringing your full creative self to the conversation. This might mean asking to see mood boards or inspiration images they've collected, or sketching rough concepts while they talk. Physical engagement with their ideas demonstrates that you're not just listening politely: you're actively processing and building on their vision.

I've noticed that clients often comment on feeling “really heard” after these focused conversations. One asset manager told me that our consultation was the first meeting with a creative professional where she forgot to check her phone for over an hour. That level of engagement became the foundation for incredible trust throughout the entire creative process.

Presence also means being comfortable with moments of silence (see strategy 2). When a client pauses to think about your question, resist the urge to fill the space with chatter. Those quiet moments often lead to the most authentic insights and create space for deeper connection.

Strategy 6: Use Compliments Strategically

Genuine compliments can be powerful relationship builders, but many creatives use them ineffectively. Empty flattery feels hollow and can actually undermine credibility. Strategic compliments, however, create positive associations that extend far beyond the immediate conversation.

The most effective compliments in professional settings aren't about personal appearance or general taste: they're about specific choices or insights that demonstrate your understanding of good work. Instead of “I love your style,” try “The way you've paired that vintage typography with contemporary imagery shows a really sophisticated understanding of visual contrast.”

Even more powerful is complimenting someone's approach or process rather than just outcomes. “I can tell you've really thought through the user experience on this project”, or “Your attention to how this will translate across different media shows real strategic thinking.”

The psychological principle at work here is called spontaneous trait transference. When you speak positively about someone else, listeners unconsciously associate those positive qualities with you as well. So when you praise a client's thoughtful approach to their project, they begin to see you as equally thoughtful.
This strategy works particularly well when networking or meeting with potential collaborators. Acknowledging specific aspects of someone's work shows that you've done your homework and can recognise quality when you see it. It positions you as a peer rather than someone seeking their approval.

During industry events, I make it a point to research some of the speakers beforehand and identify specific projects or approaches I genuinely admire. Mentioning these during conversations creates immediate common ground and often leads to deeper discussions about creative process and philosophy.
That's how my long-standing friendship with David Carson started: I wasn't just the millionth designer flattering him, but I put myself at a different level by having a deeper conversation about Design with him. It doesn't always work and it depends on who you're facing: Neville Brody was too full of himself to entertain a similar discussion (sorry Neville, but it's true).

Strategy 7: Share Carefully Chosen Insights

One of the fastest ways to establish credibility is to offer a small piece of valuable information or perspective that the client hadn't considered. This doesn't mean overwhelming them with technical details or showing off your expertise: it means sharing insights that demonstrate your strategic thinking.

For photographers, this might involve highlighting lighting considerations for their venue that could impact the final images, or suggesting timeline adjustments to enhance the quality of their coverage. When a collector buys my prints, I offer to consult on the placement and lighting. For designers, it could be mentioning how a particular approach would affect their brand's scalability or identifying opportunities they hadn't considered.

The key is offering these insights as collaborative observations rather than corrections or criticisms. “I noticed your venue has these beautiful east-facing windows; if we time the portraits for late afternoon, we could capture some really stunning natural light” sounds helpful and considerate. “Your timeline doesn't account for proper lighting” sounds critical and dismissive.

These small moments of added value demonstrate that you're thinking beyond just fulfilling their stated requirements. You're considering their broader success and looking for ways to improve their outcomes. This positions you as a partner in their project rather than just a hired service provider.
The most effective insights often connect creative decisions to business outcomes. Explaining how a particular design choice will improve user engagement, or how specific photography approaches will enhance their brand credibility, shows that you understand the bigger picture beyond just making pretty pictures.

Strategy 8: Maintain Positive Energy

Research consistently shows that emotional states are contagious. When you bring genuine enthusiasm and positive energy to a first meeting, clients unconsciously mirror those feelings and begin to associate them with working with you. However, this doesn't mean being artificially upbeat or ignoring legitimate concerns.

Authentic positive energy comes from genuine excitement about creative problem-solving. When a client describes their vision or challenges, let your natural curiosity and enthusiasm show. Ask engaging questions. Express genuine interest in their goals. Share your excitement about potential creative approaches.

This is particularly important when dealing with stressed or overwhelmed clients. Brides planning weddings, executives facing tight deadlines, or small business owners launching new ventures often come to first meetings carrying significant anxiety. Your calm, positive energy can be incredibly reassuring.

But positive energy must be appropriate to the context. A corporate client dealing with a crisis communications situation needs confident competence more than boundless enthusiasm. A couple planning an intimate wedding might prefer warm, gentle energy over high-energy excitement. Read the room and calibrate accordingly.
The goal is to leave clients feeling more optimistic and confident about their project after meeting with you than they did before. When someone walks away from a consultation feeling energised and excited about the possibilities, they're much more likely to move forward with you.

Strategy 9: Find and Emphasise Common Ground

Humans are naturally drawn to people who seem similar to themselves. This principle, known as the similarity-attraction effect, can be leveraged powerfully in professional relationships. Look for genuine points of connection: shared values, similar approaches to problem-solving, or common experiences in your respective industries.

This extends beyond surface-level connections, such as mutual acquaintances or shared alma maters. Look for deeper alignment around professional philosophy, creative process, or business approach. Perhaps you both prioritise sustainability in your work, or you've both navigated similar challenges in building your businesses.
During wedding consultations, I often discovered that couples and I shared similar values around authenticity versus perfection, or the importance of documenting real emotions rather than just staged moments. These alignments became the foundation for incredibly strong working relationships because we were genuinely motivated by the same things.

For business clients, common ground might emerge around shared understanding of brand building, user experience, or market positioning. When a client realises that you think about their challenges in the same way they do, they immediately feel more confident in your ability to solve them.

The key is authenticity. Don't manufacture similarities that don't exist, but do take time to explore areas where your values and approaches naturally align. These connections often become the basis for long-term professional relationships that extend far beyond individual projects.

Strategy 10: Demonstrate Genuine Vulnerability

While we discussed strategic vulnerability earlier, there's another level that can create a profound connection: genuine moments of openness about your creative process or professional journey. This isn't about sharing personal problems or professional failures: it's about being authentic about your humanity.

This might mean acknowledging when you're genuinely excited about a creative challenge they've presented, or admitting that their project pushes you into new creative territory in ways that energise you. Creative professionals often feel pressure to appear as if every project is routine, but clients actually find it reassuring to know their project genuinely interests you.

“I have to admit, the combination of architectural photography and environmental storytelling you're looking for is exactly the kind of challenge that gets me excited. I've been wanting to explore that intersection more deeply,” creates a much stronger connection than pretending it's just another day at the office.

This vulnerability also extends to being honest about your process. If you typically need time to think through creative approaches rather than generating ideas on the spot, say so. If you do your best work through collaborative refinement rather than presenting finished concepts, be sure to communicate that. Clients appreciate understanding how you work rather than being left to guess.
The goal is to come across as a real person who happens to be exceptionally good at their creative profession, rather than a creative robot who produces work without genuine engagement.

Strategy 11: Show Up Consistently

In an industry where many professionals are inconsistent with communication, simply being reliable creates a powerful first impression with clients. This means responding to emails within reasonable timeframes, arriving punctually for meetings, and following through on small commitments made during initial conversations. I have to admit, I'm not the best at this myself. Because of my ADHD, or just not feeling it at times.

But consistency goes beyond basic professionalism. It's about demonstrating that your attention to detail and reliability in communication will extend to your creative work. When you promise to send additional portfolio examples and then do so promptly, clients begin to trust that you'll handle their project with the same care and attention.

This consistency is particularly important in the follow-up period after initial meetings. Many potential client relationships dissolve not because of poor initial meetings, but because of inconsistent follow-up communication. A simple email thanking them for their time and reiterating key points from your conversation can set you apart from competitors who let these moments slip by.

Consistency also means maintaining the same level of energy and professionalism, whether you're meeting with a small local business or a major corporate client. Clients can sense when you're treating them differently based on project size or prestige, and it immediately undermines trust.

Strategy 12: Leave Them Wanting More

The most memorable first impressions often leave clients feeling intrigued rather than overwhelmed. Instead of overwhelming initial meetings with every portfolio piece and service option, focus on creating genuine curiosity about working with you.
This might involve showcasing a curated selection of your strongest, most relevant work, rather than a comprehensive portfolio review. Or sharing one compelling insight about their project while hinting at additional ideas you'd explore if working together. The goal is to demonstrate your capabilities while making it clear that the real creative work would happen through collaboration.

End meetings with a clear sense of what the next steps would look like, but don't pressure for immediate decisions. Something like: “I'd love to put together a more detailed creative approach for you to consider. Would it be helpful if I sent that along early next week?” creates forward momentum without seeming pushy.

The psychology here relates to what marketers call the curiosity gap: people are naturally drawn to complete unfinished narratives. When clients leave your meeting with a sense that there's more to discover about your creative approach, they're much more likely to continue the conversation.

The Long View: Building Relationships Beyond First Meetings

These strategies work because they're based on fundamental principles of human psychology rather than superficial tactics. When you approach first meetings with genuine curiosity, authentic enthusiasm, and strategic vulnerability, you're not just trying to win individual projects—you're building the foundation for long-term professional relationships.

The creative industry increasingly rewards professionals who can develop ongoing client partnerships rather than just completing one-off projects. Clients want to work with creatives they trust, understand, and enjoy spending time with. The most successful photographers and designers I know have built their businesses on relationships that span years and multiple projects.

This relationship-building approach becomes even more important as artificial intelligence and automated services handle more routine creative tasks. What can't be automated is the human connection, the strategic thinking, and the collaborative creative process that emerges from strong professional relationships.

Remember that every first meeting is practice for the next one. The more you apply these psychology-backed strategies, the more natural they become. Soon, creating a positive first impression with clients won't require conscious effort: it will be simply how you show up professionally.

Your Next Steps

Making a brilliant first impression with clients, colleagues, models, etc. isn't about perfecting a performance or following a script. It's about becoming more intentional in how you connect with people and more strategic in demonstrating your value as both a creative professional and a collaborative partner.

Start by choosing one or two of these strategies to focus on during your next client meetings. Pay attention to how clients respond differently when you lead with curiosity rather than credentials, or when you create genuine presence rather than just going through consultation motions.

Remember that in our increasingly digital world, the ability to create authentic human connections has become a competitive advantage. Clients can find talented creatives anywhere, but they choose to work with people who make them feel understood, valued, and excited about their projects.

The investment you make in mastering these first impression strategies will pay dividends throughout your career. Not just in winning more projects, but in working with better clients, commanding higher rates, and building the kind of creative practice that energises you rather than drains you.

Your creative talent brought you this far. Your ability to connect with clients will take you wherever you want to go next.

Key Research References

Aside from everything I experienced first-hand in about 30 years in the Creative industry, here is some of the research I used to support the argument of this article.

• Princeton Research (1-second impressions)
  • Willis, J., & Todorov, A. (2006). First impressions: Making up your mind after a 100-ms exposure to a face. Psychological Science, 17(7), 592-598 (PDF): http://psych.princeton.edu/psychology/research/todorov/pdf/Willis&Todorov-PsychScience.pdf
• Chameleon Effect Research
  • Chartrand, T. L., & Bargh, J. A. (1999). The chameleon effect: The perception–behavior link and social interaction. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 76(6), 893-910: https://pubmed.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/10402679/
• Amy Cuddy's First Impressions Research
  • Referenced from her Wired interview: https://www.wired.com/2012/11/amy-cuddy-first-impressions/
• Mirror Neurons Research
  • Ferrari, P. F., & Coudé, G. (2018). Mirror neurons, embodied emotions, and empathy. Neuropsychologia: https://positivepsychology.com/mirror-neurons/
• Business Psychology Research
  • From the Frontiers in Psychology study on mimicry in customer service: https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/psychology/articles/10.3389/fpsyg.2023.1016125/full
• 2024 Creative Industry Data
  • From a LinkedIn article on creative professional trends: https://www.linkedin.com/pulse/2024-trends-creative-professionals-workwithfunnel-i7h3e
  • Photography industry survey data: https://aftershoot.com/blog/photography-industry-trends/
• Networking and Professional Relationships
  • LinkedIn networking statistics from: https://www.myshortlister.com/insights/networking
  • Creative networking research: https://council.rollingstone.com/blog/powerful-networking-for-creative-professionals-10-tips-for-success
• First Impressions Override Later Positive Impressions
  • Science Daily article (2014): “First impressions really are lasting impressions”: http://www.sciencedaily.com/releases/2014/02/140214111207.htm
• The “Pratfall Effect” (People Like You More After Mistakes)
  • Aronson, E., Willerman, B., & Floyd, J. (1966). The effect of a pratfall on increasing interpersonal attractiveness. Psychonomic Science, 4(6), 227-228: http://psycnet.apa.org/record/1966-05356-001
• Mere Exposure Effect (Liking People We See Often)
  • Zajonc, R. B. (1968). Attitudinal effects of mere exposure. Journal of Personality and Social Psychology, 9(2), 1-27: https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/002210319290055O
• Self-Disclosure and Closeness
  • Research on personal conversations making strangers feel closer: http://www.businessinsider.com/questions-psychologist-says-can-make-you-fall-in-love-2015-1
• Similarity-Attraction Effect:
  • Byrne, D. (1971). The Attraction Paradigm. Academic Press: http://psycnet.apa.org/record/1957-07607-001

Additional Psychology Research

• Similarity-attraction effect and spontaneous trait transference studies can be found in standard social psychology textbooks
• The “talking about ourselves activates reward centres” research is from Harvard's neuroscience studies on self-disclosure
• Studies show that trustworthiness and likeability are linked to vocal delivery and tone of voice
• Multiple studies in this area are often referenced in social psychology literature on paralinguistics.